[ISBN: 978-1-935982-21-0; 270 pp; $21 in U.S.] In recent years, Pakistan has assumed increasing importance in American thinking as the place in which Washington's "AfPak" policy has became worryingly mired. But Pakistan's 175 million people have had their own history throughout these years, too: a history that was complex, enthralling, infuriating, and inspiring-- sometimes, all at once. How lucky, then, that we now have Manan Ahmed to guide us into the intricacies of the imbroglio between these two complicated countries.
Since 2004 Ahmed, a deeply informed Pakistani-American historian, has been casting his keen and always wry eye on the U.S.-Pakistani interaction on his blog, "Chapati Mystery. Where the Wild Frontiers Are: Pakistan and the American Imagination is his own curation of the most trenchant of these blog posts-- a work that will forever change the way its American readers think about Pakistan. (And in an Epilogue penned in May 2011, he offers some final reflections on the multiple meanings that the U.S. killing of Osama Bin Laden in Pakistan that month had for the centuries-long interaction between Pakistan's people and the 'West'.)
In September 2010, Ahmed was reflecting on the "failure of imagination" on behalf of U.S. officials, to which the authors of the American 9/11 Commission report ascribed the officials' failure to prevent the 9/11 attacks. To combat terrorism, he noted, the report's authors thought American officials needed to work harder on developing a more specifically novelistic (à la Tom Clancy) kind of imagination: "the capacity to imagine this Other, to give them an interiority, a mindfulness, an agency, a history."
But it did not work out that way. Where the Wild Frontiers Are vividly captures the failure of most members of the U.S. elite to successfully "imagine" the reality of people's lives and society in Pakistan in this important way. Ahmed unsparingly criticizes most of the so-called "experts" who prognosticate about Pakistan and its region in the U.S. mainstream media. About Robert Kaplan, he writes that ""The empire... will surely invite him to speak to groups with shinier brass and shinier domes. The historians reading [his] book will have less cause to be charitable". A similar charge, he lays at the feet of Rory Stewart and Greg Mortenson.
Where the Wild Frontiers Are looks clear-headedly at U.S. imaginings about Pakistan-- and also at the big historical and political trends within Pakistan itself. The Lawyers' Movement, the self-destructive last days of Pervez Musharraf's presidency, the assassination of Benazir Bhutto, the eruption of a vicious anti-Ahmadi pogrom, the disruptions and suffering caused by the 'Global War on Terror', the country's endless tangling with the complexities of its own past and meaning: All are the object of Ahmed's steady (and sometimes exasperated) gaze.
Between them, the book's ten chapters provide a compelling picture of the complexity of the U.S.-Pakistan entanglement in the first decade of this century.
Posted by Mr. Peacock on 4th Jun 2012
This book gave me an amazing lively example of what it means for an academic as well as for anyone else to fight for justice. Ahmed brings political engagement to a great level of intelligence, humor and critique, proving that there is no journalism or academia possible without a sense of love and care. Facing the madness of the last 10 years of war, he is able to dismantel uncountable lies and ideological manipulations, and offer us a representation of reality that is more true, more nuanced, more vivid, and finally, more moral. Under is pen, all the empires of the world are revealed in the bare nudity of their ignorant monstrousity.
Manan Ahmed speaks the voice of people. People from Pakistan, people from around the world, people who suffered, are suffering and will probably continue to suffer, but people who struggle for their lives and dignity and will not let injustice being endlessly perpetuated. With love and care, always.
Posted by Angie on 4th Jun 2012
I'm done with my studies, but if I were to ever write another forced paper on Pakistan, I would read this book and source it heavily....... or just read it to up my conversation potential at cocktail parties. It's always best to approach Pakistani politics with a line of comical cynicism and Manan Ahmed does not disappoint. I find this book to be less slanted then most in this genre, but having more confidence than just the standard, 'Islam is not bad.' rhetoric. I have a feeling this will be the first in a long series of books on the region from this author.
Prices listed are all in US$. Ebook prices are the same worldwide. Prices for print books are shown in the first instance for ship-to addresses in the USA. Once you click on your ship-to country, your actual price will come up, in red. Free shipping on all orders over $40 shipped to one address. If buying five or more books, ask us about discounts!